12/17/2019 |
Kyle |
Hatch |
New York Bicycling Coalition (NYBC), and Environmental Design and Research (EDR) |
Albany |
New York |
There is a lot of emphasis on accommodating electric vehicles. This is a great step in the right direction but more investment and resources should be allocated to active transportation modes. The... read more There is a lot of emphasis on accommodating electric vehicles. This is a great step in the right direction but more investment and resources should be allocated to active transportation modes. The majority of trips within U.S communities are less than 5 miles, distances that are easily covered by bicycles, scooters, and pedestrian modes of transportation.
We should think of our transportation usage like the food pyramid (outdated now, I know) with active transportation modes functioning as the base of the pyramid. We need to build policies and environments that make these forms of transportation the default mode for the majority of our trips. |
- |
2/6/2020 |
Bob |
Zerrillo |
New York Public Transit Association |
Albany |
New York |
The New York Public Transit Association (NYPTA), which represents more than 100 transit systems throughout New York State, supports the goals of the TCI effort. The development of a cap and... read more The New York Public Transit Association (NYPTA), which represents more than 100 transit systems throughout New York State, supports the goals of the TCI effort. The development of a cap and invest program is both consistent with the environmental and energy objectives of public transportation and is a way to increase funding for public transportation to transition to low emission transit vehicles and to expand transit service.
NYPTA offers the following comments on the TCI draft MOU:
• NYPTA supports the goals and objectives of the TCI cap and invest program proposal.
• NYPTA supports the intent to invest program proceeds in low carbon and clean mobility options in urban, suburban and rural communities, and specifically in public transportation.
• Greater investment to modernize and enhance public transportation throughout New York State supports the goals of the TCI program, particularly greater investment to support the transition to cleaner public transportation infrastructure and to increase public transportation services.
• In developing the program, TCI should consider the impact on transit systems in small communities and rural areas, which have fewer resources and where the transition to clean fuel vehicles may take much longer. The increased cost of diesel fuel and gasoline to transit systems in these areas that will result from the cap and invest program will be burdensome and could negatively impact the continuation of these essential transit services to customers who need them most. An exemption (or credit) from any increase in fuel prices for public transportation services resulting from a carbon cap should be considered in designing the program in order to mitigate any negative financial impacts.
• NYPTA strongly supports returning the proceeds generated from the cap and invest program to the state where they are generated or earned.
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the draft MOU.
|
- |
2/22/2020 |
Alaina |
Boyle |
E4TheFuture |
Albany |
New York |
Transforming our transportation to a clean and efficient system is essential to meeting the climate goals of the next decade and preventing catastrophic climate change, around the world as well as... read more Transforming our transportation to a clean and efficient system is essential to meeting the climate goals of the next decade and preventing catastrophic climate change, around the world as well as in our own state. Transportation is one of the top source of greenhouse gas emissions, and the TCI will build on the success of RGGI in coordinating the climate leadership in NY and the northeast. Please take this essential leadership role in the fight against climate change for this and future generations, and join the TCI. |
- |
2/27/2020 |
Mark |
Kresowik |
Sierra Club |
Albany |
New York |
The Sierra Club is sharing the attached 1,463 comments from our members and supporters in New York supporting finalizing the Draft Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) of the Transportation and... read more The Sierra Club is sharing the attached 1,463 comments from our members and supporters in New York supporting finalizing the Draft Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) of the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). Thank you for helping to design a regional policy to limit climate pollution from motor fuels and invest in a modern, clean, transportation future. The evidence is clear: the more we limit pollution from motor fuels, the more jobs are created, the more the economy grows, and the more lives we save. Please sign on to the agreement to implement a strong, equitable regional climate protection policy through TCI. Invest in the communities that have suffered the most from burning gasoline and have the least access to clean transportation options. Stop sending our hard-earned dollars out of the state to oil companies, and choose to create jobs, grow the economy, and save lives for families and businesses. Thank you. |
NY TCI 1463 signers 27 Feb 2020.pdf |
2/28/2020 |
Hannah |
Dreissigacker |
Vermont |
Albany |
Vermont |
Governor Scott- It is critical that Vermont join the TCI. It is a good deal for Vermont economically, and a key step in reducing Vermont's transportation CO2 emissions, which have been rising... read more Governor Scott- It is critical that Vermont join the TCI. It is a good deal for Vermont economically, and a key step in reducing Vermont's transportation CO2 emissions, which have been rising despite our green image and good efforts. Cap-and-invest programs like TCI are proven to work; lowering CO2 emissions and actually increasing GDP. Please, please, please do the right thing for all of us and Vermont join the TCI.
Sincerely,
Hannah Dreissigacker |
- |
2/28/2020 |
James |
Calvin |
New York Association of Convenience Stores |
Albany |
New York |
Please see attached. Thank you. Please see attached. Thank you. |
TCI draft MOU comments.docx |
10/16/2020 |
Anastasia |
Gordon |
Alliance for Clean Energy NY |
Albany |
New York |
ACE NY comments on the proposed equity strategies for TCI. ACE NY comments on the proposed equity strategies for TCI. |
Comments on TCI Equity Strategies.pdf |
11/12/2019 |
albert |
settembro |
person |
agawam |
Massachusetts |
It is not right to try to Push this Gas Tax without the Peoples Vote
It is not right to try to Push this Gas Tax without the Peoples Vote
|
- |
12/19/2019 |
Andre |
Konstant |
taxpayer |
Addison County |
Vermont |
Here we go again. A "TAX" on the "rich" that will end up being passed down to the poor via higher costs of everything that requires transportation to get it to your home: not... read more Here we go again. A "TAX" on the "rich" that will end up being passed down to the poor via higher costs of everything that requires transportation to get it to your home: not just gas, but food, too! How are renters who cannot use wood fuel, by eqregious insurance regulation, going to pay for heat? How about rising costs of food. Who benefits? Only the metro areas where mass transportation and natural gas pipelines are practical will benefit (well, at least it won't hurt their pockets as much). Now that New Hampshire has said, "NO" to this, good luck to all businesses in other states near the NH border. PLEASE, GOVERNOR SCOTT, TELL THE LEGISLATURE YOU WILL VETO ANY NEW TAX SCHEME! |
- |
12/17/2019 |
Robert |
Peterson |
Consumer |
Addison |
Maine |
This is a tremendous mistake that will not benefit Mainer's in any way. I personally drive over 400 miles per week if not more to work and school. The price of fuel is already unbearable,... read more This is a tremendous mistake that will not benefit Mainer's in any way. I personally drive over 400 miles per week if not more to work and school. The price of fuel is already unbearable, adding an additional tax will inhibit me from pursuing my career path, and providing for my family. I need a truck for what I do; building materials, groceries, tools, and more. I need to plow my driveway in the winter, have you ever seen a plow on a Prius? If you raise the taxes it will cost more to transport your beloved illegal aliens to your beloved sanctuary cities, then the local law enforcement, fire and EMS services will not have enough money budgeted to cover the increased number if calls. Great idea if you want to see people run for the hills like they are in New York under the Mook Governor Coumo... Massachusetts is not far behind, and here we go, Maine...we were on our way to better days and then they elected you...Janet Mills....do not move forward with this plan. It is a terrible idea, will only have a negative impact on Maine and Mainer's and will destroy what is left of a beautiful state to satisfy the needs of the liberal masses. |
- |
1/13/2020 |
Catherine |
Fonda |
Mrs. |
Addison |
Maine |
The earth has had warmer and colder seasons always. Check with the Univ of Maine and their core samples from Sebasticook Lake in Newport. They concluded that the earth was hotter and drier than... read more The earth has had warmer and colder seasons always. Check with the Univ of Maine and their core samples from Sebasticook Lake in Newport. They concluded that the earth was hotter and drier than now 6000 to 8000 years ago. God is in charge of the climate/atmosphere/universe and He would never allow us even the smallest charge over it. Please keep in mind while you are reducing carbon use that everything on earth uses carbon dioxide and it is necessary for life. |
- |
2/26/2020 |
George |
Carroll |
none |
Adamstown |
Maryland |
The added toll lanes to I-270 will cost Billions and years to complete. You can buy a whole lot of bus shelters and busses for that kind of money. We need to make it easier for people to get out... read more The added toll lanes to I-270 will cost Billions and years to complete. You can buy a whole lot of bus shelters and busses for that kind of money. We need to make it easier for people to get out of their cars, and sooner than later. |
- |
1/24/2020 |
Donna |
Smyers |
Vermont, New England, the US, and the planet Earth |
Adamant |
Vermont |
I am a very concerned citizen who believes that the governor's and legislators' resistance to increasing the cost of carbon is very short sighted. The only thing that reliably changes... read more I am a very concerned citizen who believes that the governor's and legislators' resistance to increasing the cost of carbon is very short sighted. The only thing that reliably changes people's behavior in this country is financial incentive. It is actually a very capitalistic and Republican manner of achieving results without the government deciding how it gets done.
TCI does not go far enough to cut carbon quickly, but it is a very important step that can be taken without major economic upheaval. We have endured gas price increases much more drastic than TCI would cause during prior gas shortages or panics. We paid up to $4/gallon not that long ago. When we did, people bought smaller cars and carpooled and used public transit or stayed home more. They had to. That is a price that we should pay now, and use the funds generated to help people who can least afford the price increases to change their mode of transportation and decrease their heating fuel needs. Upgrading vehicles and weatherization for those least able to pay will give them long term economic benefits from the price increases and help VT and the world achieve the needed decrease in fossil fuel use.
If we do not pay the small price now, the cost in disaster mitigation will dwarf the cost of TCI. Even though we are a small portion of worldwide CO2 emissions, Vermont must do its part. Every single portion counts. If we do not do it, everyone may not do it. We all must pay a price for the excesses of the last century or pay a much bigger price later. Delaying aggressive action is like obtaining an extremely high interest loan--it will come due and we will pay for it.
Please approve joining into the Transportation Climate Initiative now.
Thank you,
Donna Smyers |
- |
11/8/2019 |
Corinne |
Hogseth |
Voter |
Acton |
Massachusetts |
I am against Massachusetts entering into this agreement without a vote of the legislature. This is a gas tax, pure and simple, that they’ll be able to impose on drivers — particularly commuters—... read more I am against Massachusetts entering into this agreement without a vote of the legislature. This is a gas tax, pure and simple, that they’ll be able to impose on drivers — particularly commuters— without never recording a vote. I suspect this is considered a “feature” by legislators from other states considering joining the TCI. |
- |
11/12/2019 |
Elizabeth |
Lorenz |
Independent |
Acton |
Massachusetts |
I stand firmly against the TCI. It's not a climate initiative. It's a money grab from the already over burdened tax payers of Massachusetts. My family and I will be watching to see... read more I stand firmly against the TCI. It's not a climate initiative. It's a money grab from the already over burdened tax payers of Massachusetts. My family and I will be watching to see who votes for this travesty and we will vote against them in their next election. |
- |
2/17/2020 |
Jane |
Moosbruker |
Ms |
Acton |
Massachusetts |
It is crucial to slow climate change NOW and the transportation sector is one of
the largest contributors. Please act NOW. It is crucial to slow climate change NOW and the transportation sector is one of
the largest contributors. Please act NOW. |
- |
10/14/2020 |
Aleks |
Kosowicz |
Concerned Citizen |
Abrams |
Wisconsin |
Our world is LITERALLY ON FIRE. There can be no denying we have instigated a climate crisis and must take immediate action to mitigate the worst effects of it. Enacting a TCI program that... read more Our world is LITERALLY ON FIRE. There can be no denying we have instigated a climate crisis and must take immediate action to mitigate the worst effects of it. Enacting a TCI program that addresses our carbon footprint and modes of transport is one way we can begin to do just that. Please do all you can to ensure we place a cap on carbon emissions (of at least 25%) by 2030, increase (by more than 35%) the minimum investment in overburdened and underserved communities, and invest in active transportation like better sidewalks, bicycle infrastructure, and high quality public transit. Together we MUST find and implement multiple solutions in order to maintain a habitable climate for life on earth. Thank you for doing your part. |
- |
11/12/2019 |
Barbara |
Mell |
Retired |
Abington |
Massachusetts |
This TCI is nothing but a subversive attempt to impose a new version of the automatic gas tax that we, the voters, said HELL NO to in 2014. Not everyone in Massachusetts is asleep. And those of... read more This TCI is nothing but a subversive attempt to impose a new version of the automatic gas tax that we, the voters, said HELL NO to in 2014. Not everyone in Massachusetts is asleep. And those of us who aren't are going to spread the word, as far and wide as we can, and expose you for the crooks you are. We will know who NOT to vote for in the future. |
- |
12/17/2019 |
Alyson |
Sullivan |
Massachusetts Lawmaker |
Abington |
Massachusetts |
As a Massachusetts legislator, I do not support TCI and I hope Governor Charlie Baker brings the proposal before the Massachusetts legislature for a vote. As a Massachusetts legislator, I do not support TCI and I hope Governor Charlie Baker brings the proposal before the Massachusetts legislature for a vote. |
- |
1/21/2020 |
Chris |
Jones |
Voter |
Abington |
Massachusetts |
I feel if the government funded the scientists that disagree with the "carbon caused climate change" we would have a true explanation of what is going on with the climate, but that will... read more I feel if the government funded the scientists that disagree with the "carbon caused climate change" we would have a true explanation of what is going on with the climate, but that will not be done, as it is the government elected and bureaucracy who is pushing this for additional tax revenue, and that is what it really is. This would not change anything, just cost citizens more money. I reviewed some of the responses and this is the best explanation of reality:
First, the economic side: A "carbon tax" or "gas tax" is extremely regressive and hurts low-income individual, small business, and rural communities disproportionately. The relatively MINOR emission reductions gained by this approach will do nothing to curve "climate change" and only place an unnecessary burden on low income, rural Mainers. We do not have the ability in this state not to drive. Taxes without representation is a socialist concept, not one of a free society.
Second, the scientific side. To argue that ANY reductions in emissions from the transportation sector will "reverse" climate change is silly and unscientific. To think that if the world were to stop emitting carbon tomorrow (every living organism on the planet would need to stop breathing) and then believing the climate would return to 1800's levels, is farcical. Think about it. Can humans really control the climate? Ridiculous. The biggest fraud on the American public is when the courts ruled that CO2 was an air pollutant! How can that be, when CO2 is merely part of an organism's life cycle. CO2 is not and never should be considered a pollutant. This is a manufactured crisis. If the climate changes, for whatever reason, we adapt. Has happened over the millennium. Humans adapt to their environment, they cannot control it.
SAY NO to this ill-conceived plan. NO TAXES without representation, and CO2 is NOT a pollutant. |
- |