2/7/2020 |
Anne |
Bordonaro |
Concerned citizen |
Moretown |
Vermont |
I strongly support Vermont joining the TCI because I support any mechanism that imposes an additional cost on transportation fuels (a "stick"). As we have seen in the past, only... read more I strongly support Vermont joining the TCI because I support any mechanism that imposes an additional cost on transportation fuels (a "stick"). As we have seen in the past, only increased costs will lead people to drive less and car manufacturers to produce more fuel efficient vehicles. I think a regional effort like this is essential because basic economics teaches that few businesses or states will do something (even something they know they should do) if it will put them at a competitive disadvantage. I believe the carbon emissions targets are too small and the time frame is actually too long in the TCI. I think more rapid progress toward reducing our greenhouse gas emissions is absolutely essential. Obviously, this effort is better than none, but I believe it should be more ambitious. Finally, I do worry about the impact on working class people including myself who must drive for work because there currently are no viable alternatives. VT's adoption of the TCI must be accompanied by 1) significant incentives (the "carrot") for people to purchase or lease electric or more fuel efficient vehicles and 2) legislation that mandates that the funds garnered from the program are put into public transportation infrastructure development, electric charging station infrastructure, and vehicle purchase/lease incentives to individuals. Such incentives must be high enough for lower income people to make a real difference in their purchasing options (which they currently are not) and should phase out as income rises. Having said all this, nothing in the initiative addresses the fundamental problem that we simply drive private vehicles too much, electric or otherwise. Public transportation must increase and is possible, even in rural areas like where I live. My final comment is that public information regarding the TCI has been inadequate. Even after reading all of the above and other literature, the actual mechanisms for how it will work are not clear to me. I believe this is a PR failing that must be addressed. Opponents will be successful if they can label it a "carbon tax" or unfair to the poor or whatever and proponents cannot respond effectively to these arguments if how it works isn't actually clear to the ordinary citizen. I was convinced by a conversation I had with my state senator that Vermonters will probably end up paying the additional costs regardless of whether we sign or not, without reaping any of the financial benefit. This is a huge argument for joining, especially for small markets like VT. Yet no where is this spelled out in the literature describing the program. |
- |
2/14/2020 |
Craig |
Fritz |
Concerned Citizen |
Scituate |
Massachusetts |
Please adopt this initiative immediately. We cannot afford to wait for a "perfect" plan. There will never be one. read more Please adopt this initiative immediately. We cannot afford to wait for a "perfect" plan. There will never be one. |
- |
2/17/2020 |
Nancy |
Urban |
concerned citizen |
West Hartford |
Connecticut |
We just purchased an electric car and see the need for further investment in fast charging stations. We also live in an area in which the public transportation system is basically set up for the... read more We just purchased an electric car and see the need for further investment in fast charging stations. We also live in an area in which the public transportation system is basically set up for the commuting workers in and out of Hartford, but is very inconvenient for evenings and weekends and those folks who work a non-9-5 schedule. If we as a nation are to move ahead with clean methods of transport, we need to invest in systems that people can use as an alternative to driving .
thank you. |
- |
2/17/2020 |
LINDA |
FERRATO |
CONCERNED CITIZEN |
WINDSOR LOCKS |
Connecticut |
We ONLY have one planet & we are destroying it at an extremely fast pace! We MUST STOP & think of future generatons! We ONLY have one planet & we are destroying it at an extremely fast pace! We MUST STOP & think of future generatons! |
- |
2/21/2020 |
Al |
Blake |
Concerned citizen |
Becket |
Massachusetts |
As transportation contributes the majority of carbon it is urgent that we transition to using electricity for motor vehicles, heating while ensuring no adverse impact on minorities and low income... read more As transportation contributes the majority of carbon it is urgent that we transition to using electricity for motor vehicles, heating while ensuring no adverse impact on minorities and low income folks |
- |
2/21/2020 |
Jean Marie |
VanWinkle |
Concerned Citizen |
Bedford |
Virginia |
Transportation is the number one source of climate pollution in the United States. That means it's time to totally reimagine the way that we transport people and goods.
The... read more Transportation is the number one source of climate pollution in the United States. That means it's time to totally reimagine the way that we transport people and goods.
The states of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and the city of Washington, D.C., are working on a groundbreaking policy to modernize the transportation sector under the Transportation and Climate Initiative.
In order for this regional plan to work, governors of these states and the mayor of Washington, D.C., must ensure that this transportation plan is bold enough to cut harmful transportation pollution at the scale needed to avert the climate crisis. We need a plan that holds large transportation polluters accountable for the pollution they create and invests in clean transportation solutions including:
More public transit and electric vehicle infrastructure in rural areas
Expansion of commuter rail, electric vehicles, and streets in the suburbs that are safe, walkable, and bikeable
Sustainable and equitable housing near transit and electric bus fleets in urban communities
I live in Bedford, VA, that does not currently provide options for public transportation. I am a senior citizen with a medical condition that may not allow me the privilege of driving a personal vehicle for the rest of my life even though I may be able to continue to live reasonably independently with some occasional assistance. Having access to public transportation would enable me to continue to do what I need to do as well as improve the quality of life for the planet and all of its inhabitants. I totally support the effort to provide an Amtrak train station here in Bedford as well as providing public transportation in some other form that will permit individuals of all physical capabilities to travel throughout the Town / County of Bedford as well as the surrounding region including Lynchburg and Roanoke.
|
- |
2/21/2020 |
Joe |
Pfister |
Concerned Citizen |
Brooklyn |
New York |
The draft Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) proposal is a bold step to upgrade the region’s transportation system to be more efficient, more affordable, and less polluting. Through an... read more The draft Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) proposal is a bold step to upgrade the region’s transportation system to be more efficient, more affordable, and less polluting. Through an innovative framework that cuts pollution and invests in 21st century transportation solutions, the TCI proposal would ensure today’s broken system isn’t also the region’s future.
Residents of urban, suburban, and rural communities will benefit from expanded, accessible and affordable public transportation; investments in electric buses, trucks, and other clean vehicles; resilient transportation infrastructure; improved pedestrian walkways; safe infrastructure for biking; and transit-accessible affordable housing.
However, we still need to set a minimum price on pollution and establish market protections like an “Emissions Containment Reserve” that would automatically strengthen the regional policy—and more quickly reduce transportation pollution—if the cost of doing so ends up being cheaper than expected. We’ve seen how similar elements in the region’s clean power policy design create a more robust framework, and the states should apply these lessons in the transportation sector as well.
Also important is the level of pollution reductions that the states commit to in their final policy. With transportation accounting for the largest share of climate pollution, the region’s clean transportation policy must be sufficiently bold and ambitious to ensure the scale of pollution reductions we need to address the climate crisis. |
- |
2/21/2020 |
Pat |
Foley |
concerned citizen |
Hiram |
Maine |
We need to take action, no question about it! For solutions, I favor development of electric infrastructure, including in rural areas; expansion of commuter rail systems, incentives for... read more We need to take action, no question about it! For solutions, I favor development of electric infrastructure, including in rural areas; expansion of commuter rail systems, incentives for electric vehicles, and bike lanes in urban areas; location of clean bus routes in conjunction with affordable housing in urban areas; hours of said buses to be configured with hours they are needed. The plan must also hold large transportation polluters accountable for the pollution they create. Thank you for the opportunity to comment.
|
- |
2/21/2020 |
David |
Way |
Concerned citizen |
Pottstown |
Pennsylvania |
We need a regional plan, involving the governors of regional states and the mayor of Washington, D.C., to ensure that any transportation plan is bold enough to cut harmful transportation pollution... read more We need a regional plan, involving the governors of regional states and the mayor of Washington, D.C., to ensure that any transportation plan is bold enough to cut harmful transportation pollution at the scale needed to avert the climate crisis. We need a plan that holds large transportation polluters accountable for the pollution they create and invests in clean transportation solutions including:
More public transit and electric vehicle infrastructure in rural areas
Expansion of commuter rail, electric vehicles, and streets in the suburbs that are safe, walkable, and bikeable
Sustainable and equitable housing near transit and electric bus fleets in urban communities
Please make these a priority in your plans - thank you. |
- |
2/21/2020 |
Amanda |
Smock |
concerned citizen |
Brooklyn |
New York |
Hold polluters accountable.
We need to hold hold transportation polluters *and* invest in clean transportation solutions including:
-More public transit and electric... read more Hold polluters accountable.
We need to hold hold transportation polluters *and* invest in clean transportation solutions including:
-More public transit and electric vehicle infrastructure in rural areas
-Expansion of commuter rail, electric vehicles, and streets in the suburbs that are safe, walkable, and bikeable
-Sustainable and equitable housing near transit and electric bus fleets in urban communities
We need to be bold and ambitious. We need a plan that creates clean public transportation and at the same time cuts transportation pollution. |
- |
2/22/2020 |
Liz |
D. |
Concerned Citizen |
Bronx |
New York |
We need to take action to turn this climate emergency around now. I hope that it takes place responsibly and that we purchase batteries for electric vehicles from companies who purchase minerals... read more We need to take action to turn this climate emergency around now. I hope that it takes place responsibly and that we purchase batteries for electric vehicles from companies who purchase minerals such lithium via fair trade so that countries such as Bolivia and the continent of Africa do not get exploited in the process. |
- |
2/23/2020 |
Sandra |
Robertson |
Concerned citizen |
S Weymouth, near Boston |
Massachusetts |
I used to live in Portland, Oregon. Take a look at what they are doing. All electric light rail. Walking and biking are king. Cars discouraged: expensive parking, cars not allowed on some bridges... read more I used to live in Portland, Oregon. Take a look at what they are doing. All electric light rail. Walking and biking are king. Cars discouraged: expensive parking, cars not allowed on some bridges. When new areas for light rail are proposed, once routes are established housing goes up along the lines. |
- |
2/24/2020 |
Kathleen Galligan |
Riess |
Concerned citizen |
Bristol |
Maine |
We drive a hybrid car, have recently installed solar panels on our home to reduce fossil fuel use. We are advocates of switching to alternative and renewable energies worldwide. We would support... read more We drive a hybrid car, have recently installed solar panels on our home to reduce fossil fuel use. We are advocates of switching to alternative and renewable energies worldwide. We would support TCI’s plans for increasing and encouraging introduction of electric vehicles, public transportation networks (again with an electric fleet), enticements for individuals to switch away from gas fueled cars to hybrids and electric. Maine could be an environmentally progressive leader in many ways. We could show other US states positive results from significant reduction of emissions. Right now federal legislation is hopeless while we have such an ignorant and destructive person in charge, so relying state by state seems a viable way to enact protective laws. |
- |
2/24/2020 |
Sharon |
Cunningham |
Concerned citizen |
Standish |
Maine |
It is IMPORTANT for us to use GREEN, RENEWABLE energy before we completely destroy this one planet we can inhabit as is!! It is IMPORTANT for us to use GREEN, RENEWABLE energy before we completely destroy this one planet we can inhabit as is!! |
- |
2/24/2020 |
Ed |
Piper |
Concerned Citizen |
Norwich |
Vermont |
Waste has never needed a convincing rational. Thrift was a natural virtue in my family’s post depression culture. Scarcity certainly can remind us of the value of essentials once taken for granted... read more Waste has never needed a convincing rational. Thrift was a natural virtue in my family’s post depression culture. Scarcity certainly can remind us of the value of essentials once taken for granted. I remember how the 1970’s oil embargo shook up our complacency and provoked a generation of efficiency throughout the developed world. Efficient architecture, transportation, and engineering and sweaters, wood heat, alternative energy sources and all means of minimizing consumption became enlightened virtues, almost overnight. Beauty in parsimony was in style, but not for long.
It wasn’t foresight or virtue, but the elegance of thrift and off-grid independence that guided my family’s automotive and architectural preferences in the ensuing years. The return of abundance was a relief to some however, as we returned to oversized cars, SUVs and vans, decadent home climate habits and air travel.
Before us once again is an existential opportunity to write our history re; our climate crisis. It is terrifying to consider the point of no return for our planet and what that dark end might look like for our survivors. The word is out on the street. We may have already passed the turning point.
The most effective interventions are within immediate reach. I count the heavy pickups carrying a single soul to a parking lot at a job 30 miles from home. Or the unnecessary air travel we have become accustom to or the leaky buildings we heat with carbon laden climate eroding fossil-fuels.
The time for action is so close to too late it is tempting to just concede. If there were ever a time to call on our better angels, it is now. Survival for our progeny may still be in reach. We cannot afford to postpone another minute.
Transportation remains the low hanging fruit at this juncture.
Do we need to carry that extra 1000 Lbs wherever we go?
Can we find ways to be productive without wasteful nonproductive travel?
How can we maximize the passenger payload on our routine trips?
Are there alternatives to automobiles and trucks to get around?
Why are we so afraid of planned density communities that can capitalize on efficiency while preserving open land?
The bad news is that it’s almost too late
The good is that our fate still rests in our hands.
That is why I write and why I support the Transportation and Climate Initiative. This program has a double benefit: it will incentivize people not to waste fuel with slightly higher costs at the fuel pump and it will generate the means to build an infrastructure that can create a more efficient transportation network. To my mind the choice is not a hard one when weighed against the future we will leave our children.
|
- |
2/24/2020 |
Andy |
Middleton |
concerned citizen |
Laporte |
Pennsylvania |
Please help lead the NE States to create a truly carbon neutral, or, even better, zero carbon, transportation network. There is no time to waste, and the urgency means that the goals of climate... read more Please help lead the NE States to create a truly carbon neutral, or, even better, zero carbon, transportation network. There is no time to waste, and the urgency means that the goals of climate neutral transportation for millions of Americans are far more important than the often distorted jobs vs. environment misinformation of the fossil fuel industry. We need to be fossil free as soon as possible, because, quite literally, the future of life on earth depends on it! |
- |
2/24/2020 |
Jan |
Peischl |
concerned citizen |
Allison Park |
Pennsylvania |
That’s why Governor Wolf is considering joining 11 other states and D.C. to form a regional initiative — the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) — that’s going to limit carbon emissions... read more That’s why Governor Wolf is considering joining 11 other states and D.C. to form a regional initiative — the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) — that’s going to limit carbon emissions and significantly reduce pollution from gas-guzzling cars and trucks on heavily trafficked roads. It’s a once-in-a-generation opportunity to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and raise much-needed revenue to modernize our transportation system on a regional scale, which will make it easier for everyone to get around!
Governor Wolf already committed to participating in TCI last year, and his administration is currently soliciting feedback on the program to decide if Pennsylvania will formally join. If we’re ever going to transition away from the dirty fossil fuels that are making our children sick and devastating our climate, then we have to get as many voices as we can to speak out in support of this bold initiative. Can we count you in?
Submit an official comment in support of the Transportation and Climate Initiative and a new generation of public transit >>
In your stakeholder comment, we recommend you:
-reduce pollution from transportation is a key component to reducing Pennsylvania's emissions
-public transit investments that could be made with TCI proceeds would be valuable
- leaders choose the aggressive greenhouse gas reduction target that the most recent climate science tells us we need.
- prioritize clean investments in areas overburdened by pollution and/or for those who don’t have access to transportation choices. |
- |
2/25/2020 |
Richard |
Hiscock |
Concerned citizen |
Barre |
Vermont |
As a concerned citizen I urge all leader and legislators to take strong and immediate actions to battle Climate Change. The TCI is one step toward making our planet a more livable space for us and... read more As a concerned citizen I urge all leader and legislators to take strong and immediate actions to battle Climate Change. The TCI is one step toward making our planet a more livable space for us and generations to come. |
- |
2/26/2020 |
Thom |
Fistner |
concerned citizen |
Bethlehem |
Pennsylvania |
Alarming evidence demands urgent action to reduce carbon emissions. A meaningful and comprehensive carbon reduction plan must address a wide variety of transportation modes, penalize excessive... read more Alarming evidence demands urgent action to reduce carbon emissions. A meaningful and comprehensive carbon reduction plan must address a wide variety of transportation modes, penalize excessive emissions and reward low/no emission transportation initiatives.
Increase public awareness and encourage wider cooperation.
Support effective carbon sequestration technologies and require implementation of same.
We must act promptly to overcome this global threat. |
- |
2/26/2020 |
ira |
josephs |
concerned citizen |
Media |
Pennsylvania |
Climate Change is the most important issue we face - it effects everyone and is already causing extreme weather that costs taxpayers dearly.
Transportation is the sector having the most... read more Climate Change is the most important issue we face - it effects everyone and is already causing extreme weather that costs taxpayers dearly.
Transportation is the sector having the most detrimental effect so we need to do something. It shouldn't be too hard to get folks out of their cars with some infrastructure changes and the TCI Regional Policy Design seems like the way. Please support this! Like so many areas where we need to make positive changes, it is a matter of standing up to large corporations that care for their profits over the affected citizens. |
- |