|
11/21/2019 |
David |
Heisler |
retired Vermont Native |
NEW HAVEN |
Vermont |
What in the heck are all of you trying to do in the state of Vermont. Our legislature has made our state affordable for all except the rich and the people on welfare. This ends up being another... read more What in the heck are all of you trying to do in the state of Vermont. Our legislature has made our state affordable for all except the rich and the people on welfare. This ends up being another tax on the working class of the state that are already overburdened with with the expense of living here. This is a rural state where people have to drive to get to a job that pays a pittance to what other areas of the country pay for the same work. Please reconsider this tax and get the heck out of the 12 state plan. You have priced my family and other families out of the state. We will be leaving in the spring. YOU WILL NOT GET ANY MORE TAXES FROM US! |
- |
|
2/28/2020 |
Kathryn |
Kamo |
retired USDA |
Columbia |
Maryland |
Earth is being exploited by those who are fracking, drilling for oil, and removing other natural resources. It is imperative that the carbon emissions be capped as soon as possible and other... read more Earth is being exploited by those who are fracking, drilling for oil, and removing other natural resources. It is imperative that the carbon emissions be capped as soon as possible and other means of transportation developed as well as other sources of natural energy. I fully support the initiatives and goals of TCI. |
- |
|
10/30/2019 |
Laurent And June |
Hourcle |
Retired USAF Colonel and GWU law professor |
Saco |
Maine |
We desperately need to catch up with Europe on mass transportation and EV’s, Coupled with this should be a move toward roof top solar distributed electric production to replace our current “... read more We desperately need to catch up with Europe on mass transportation and EV’s, Coupled with this should be a move toward roof top solar distributed electric production to replace our current “single point of failure “ electric grid. That coupled with EV’s and “autopilot mass transit” will reap substantial savings not to mention the cost avoidance of limiting catastrophe costs from not coping sooner with global climate change . There is a reason insurance companies are leaders in climate change warnings, there will also be savings in medical costs due to reducing air and water pollution from fossil fuel exploitation (drilling/mining,transportation and use. |
- |
|
12/23/2019 |
CAPT Donald P |
Galamaga USN Ret |
Retired US Navy Ship Command Qualified Officer |
Warwick |
Rhode Island |
Weather and its relationship to long term Climate Change dynamics have always been a subject of professional interest and application for me during my active service with the United States Navy... read more Weather and its relationship to long term Climate Change dynamics have always been a subject of professional interest and application for me during my active service with the United States Navy and in retirement in matters of communication with similarly interested colleagues and community members, including members of the Rhode Island House of Representative and Senate and local City Council members as it related to shoreline degradation and change and changes in the characteristics of our waterways. I am seriously concerned that much of the advocacy of persons with public administrative and political policy responsibilities have, too often identified with activities more focused on "consensus" rather than knowledge acquisition both directly and indirectly to the causes and effects of weather and long term climate results and trends and cycles. Unfortunately, for Rhode Island, the TCI Regional Policy design finds itself as completely unsatisfactory for the people of this state and needs to be rejected outright. Our Governor may have good intentions but she has been misled by the politicization of a topic which recommends a directions which may well rebound negatively to the economic and well being environment of RHode Island residents and visitors. Recent former NASA scientists and climate professionals have, in an macro set of analyses, that actions and directions as indicated by the TCI policy design begin to have a deleterious effect when about one third of the actions undertaken begin to have a negative macro effect on various carbon creation remediation activities, increasing rather than decreasing the overall carbon footprint based on the realistic need for reliable energy generation to support expansion of alternative energy activity. Additionally, this effect then expands to log kinds of trend proportions, meaning that attempts to reduce this effect until alternative energy balance is achieved costs even more than replacement benefit intended. The cost to taxpayers and ratepayers and mobile replacement remediation replacement would be enormous, again, even if only one third of the TCI policies were implemented. Recall, that tax benefit already exists to support commercial viability of alternative mobile and energy operations. The windmill experiment is supported by an infinite cost of operation escalator to keep viable. At the same time, climate claims about the albedo of the earth are being placed into doubt as the sun seems to have moved into its cooling posture and plate tectonic movements now are causing some scientists to indicated that waters are not rising in some costal venues. Rather subsidence of large portions of plates may be the cause of "deeper" waters. These conclusions need long term analysis and warn that consensus oriented policies regarding climate need much further studies before the first penny of added taxation or fees are dedicated to what in reality is consensus exaggeration. This is critical, in that, in Rhode Island, long term neglect of the infrastructure of the state has resulted in poor bridges, dams, public buildings and schools, not to mention health care facilities and the need for alternative rail and road access to places like Hartford, CT, which is going thru an economic renewal. The current TCI policy supporters have been luuled to sleep by some who claim that energy production needs from oil and natural gas are on their way out. tell that to the citizens of Middletown and Newport and some of Portsmouth. In 2019, we have a the smallest state in the union which does not have 100% residential access to natural gas lines or water lines that have been renewed or electric transmission lines that leak badly. Much need to be done now before RI decides to go on a radical "consensus" exploration. Very bad, Governor. Time to examine what benefit we get from regional committees who have done nothing for the state to have full flowing access to traditional energy, some of which leaks from Boston ports that get very cold or hot weather LNG from Russia. Time to stop this foolishness. The governor is on her way out and appears to be seeking camaraderie with public political endeavors that her party presidential candidates are highlighting to the public, it seems with not much success. Stop this endeavor. It is wrong. |
- |
|
10/28/2019 |
Nancy |
Bliss |
Retired teacher |
Brunswick |
Maine |
I support the transportation climate initiative.
We as responsible citizens need to help alleviate greenhouse gases and other pollutants and must find suitable means of transportation that... read more I support the transportation climate initiative.
We as responsible citizens need to help alleviate greenhouse gases and other pollutants and must find suitable means of transportation that use less or no fossil fuel.
We need to come up with more public transportation which is accessible to more people and more convenient.
Nancy Bliss |
- |
|
10/29/2019 |
Susan |
Caiazza |
Retired teacher |
Liverpool |
New York |
I am concerned about the cost of this initiative and would like to know the expected cost increase to a gallon of gasoline I am concerned about the cost of this initiative and would like to know the expected cost increase to a gallon of gasoline |
- |
|
2/21/2020 |
Evelyn |
Farbman |
retired teacher |
Middletown |
Connecticut |
If the world is to be habitable for our grandchildren, transportation will have to be transformed. So will many other energy-dependent areas of human life, but transportation may be the easiest... read more If the world is to be habitable for our grandchildren, transportation will have to be transformed. So will many other energy-dependent areas of human life, but transportation may be the easiest to address. Let's get started on the changes now. |
- |
|
2/24/2020 |
Ann |
Carman |
Retired teacher |
Scarborough |
Maine |
I am in favor of anything we can do, especially in terms of transportation, to mitigate the effects of climate change. This is for the sake of our children and grandchildren. I am in favor of anything we can do, especially in terms of transportation, to mitigate the effects of climate change. This is for the sake of our children and grandchildren. |
- |
|
1/16/2020 |
George |
Carroll |
Retired Small Business Owner |
Frederick |
Maryland |
Dear Sir,
I am a concerned citizen. We need to have a national policy to greatly reduce transportation pollution. There are currently no major US manufacturers making all electric trucks.... read more Dear Sir,
I am a concerned citizen. We need to have a national policy to greatly reduce transportation pollution. There are currently no major US manufacturers making all electric trucks. This needs to change, as truck exhaust in the cities are a major pollution concern. People need to be given incentives to use public transportation that is cleaner, reliable and more convenient. Our current state of affairs is unsustainable. The technology exists for this. We just need the national will to do it.
Sincerely,
George D. Carroll |
- |
|
10/7/2020 |
Bill |
Overholtz |
Retired scientist |
East Falmouth |
Massachusetts |
1. need a dedicated source of funding for this initiative.
2. Need more fast charging stations, with standardized hookups, distributed in strategic locations.
3. Need to move... read more 1. need a dedicated source of funding for this initiative.
2. Need more fast charging stations, with standardized hookups, distributed in strategic locations.
3. Need to move quickly in providing incentives for electric busses and medium commercial vehicles.
4. Need to move much more quickly with onshore wind, solar pv, solar hot water, and energy efficiency’s.
5. Above all, we need to proceed quickly with a variety of initiatives. We don’t have decades, we have a few years at best. Please convey to the decision makers that we act quickly. |
- |
|
2/28/2020 |
Ron |
Boyer |
retired science teacher |
Grantsville |
Maryland |
I support the Transportation & Climate Initiative! I support the Transportation & Climate Initiative! |
- |
|
1/17/2020 |
Aviva |
Brecher |
retired research scientist and policy planner |
Belmont |
Massachusetts |
This is an excellent and comprehensive bottom-up regional initiative, but it cannot supplant the necessary comprehensive and overarching national clean transportation policy and regulations.... read more This is an excellent and comprehensive bottom-up regional initiative, but it cannot supplant the necessary comprehensive and overarching national clean transportation policy and regulations. States must continue to press Congress and the Administration to recognize and address the acute and interlinked climate change, energy and transportation crisis. More emphasis is needed on a smooth transition to clean energy sources for transportation vehicles and to rebuilding decayed infrastructure, or developing and deploying new infrastructure, such as chargers for electric buses and cars. |
- |
|
1/5/2020 |
Wm F |
Horan |
Retired Raytheon |
Middletown |
Rhode Island |
RI Energy CZAR failed us! Yes, an inferior solution equates to an inferior product. Electric vehicles remain a wet dream given a flawed electricity affordability & availability. The back door... read more RI Energy CZAR failed us! Yes, an inferior solution equates to an inferior product. Electric vehicles remain a wet dream given a flawed electricity affordability & availability. The back door carbon Tax is a niggardly end run lacking in reality.
The reason renewables can’t power modern civilization is because they were never meant to. One interesting question is why and or how anybody ever thought they could? Never the less RI like Germany still embraces an already failed in Europe wind & solar industrial complex GREEN SUICIDE. TODAY'S Snow storm & Polar Vortex weather events evening reading material, before the lights go out, for RI elected officials! Given the US Congress budget reflects a beginning for a already failed in Europe flawed wind and solar industrial complex subsidies phaseout - a much better understanding for all the components & limitations of wind & solar generated electricity is mandatory! The rational solution can be found!
Many Researchers have been underestimating the true cost and utility of wind and solar generated electricity!
This question comes up in many types of evaluations, including Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE), Energy Return on Energy Invested (EROI), Life Cycle Analysis (LCA), and Energy Payback Period (EPP).
Conclusions;
a) Several adjustments need to be made to make wind and solar EROIs comparable to fossil fuels or generation IV Nuclear fission. The biggest of these is adjusting to remove intermittency (strength of wind & solar is every changing even beyond the day night cycle)..
b) Back of the envelope estimates would suggest that if the adjustments are made EROIs for Wind & Solar are likely less than 1.0 hence not a feasible solutions especially when compared to lower cost & predictable alternatives! Perhaps, The very BIG IF an EROI as low as 3:1 might be useful, then there is a possibility that some wind energy would be helpful, especially if a particular wind location has a very high capacity factor (can generate electricity a large share of the time), and IF both hostile environment induced rapid equipment attrition & complex under water transmission line hubs resultant companion pricing problems can be handled adequately. The EROI of solar PV would probably still be too low in most applications, especially in the northern US locations.
c) EROI can be a starting point for analysis, just as for example in preliminary medical models et al. However it is necessary, especially where a) energy acquisition b) energy conversion to power & c) power - electricity distribution, to look at real world outcomes. Yes, in this case actual outcomes can be very different than claims by an equipment vendor or an aligned an over sold political cult having unknowingly drank the green Kool-Aid.
In any event, we need to be examining situations more closely, instead of simply assuming that hidden subsidies now buried in your electricity Bills & state + federal tax bills can be counted on indefinitely. Today the US Congress is looking at retiring W&S subsidies after 20 + years of tax & rate payer monies squandered ! |
- |
|
1/16/2020 |
Karen |
Hoy |
Retired professor |
Norfolk |
Virginia |
A clean, efficient and fast train line from the mid-Atlantic states to Maine would be a big step to reducing air polution. A clean, efficient and fast train line from the mid-Atlantic states to Maine would be a big step to reducing air polution. |
- |
|
10/14/2020 |
ROBERT M |
COHEN MD |
Retired Physician |
PHILADELPHIA PA 19130 |
Pennsylvania |
It has come to the point where mankind either severely limits global CO2 and methane emissions or pay the consequences. Those consequences have already started and are accelerating at a rapid... read more It has come to the point where mankind either severely limits global CO2 and methane emissions or pay the consequences. Those consequences have already started and are accelerating at a rapid rate. Think of the expanding number of hurricanes, the horrific fires in California, in other western states, Australia, the Brazilian Amazon, etc., etc. The melting of permafrost in the north is already releasing huge quantities of stored methane. It goes on and on. Quite frankly, to MY view, it is already too late to avoid massive changes to the earth's climate which endanger every aspect of life, including the lives of mankind. This initiative is a MUST! |
- |
|
10/30/2019 |
Pamela |
Strong |
Retired Maine State Employee |
Waterville |
Maine |
With an average per capita income in Maine of slightly over $53K and 25% of its residents receiving Social Security...myself included) it occurs to me that most residents would not be able to... read more With an average per capita income in Maine of slightly over $53K and 25% of its residents receiving Social Security...myself included) it occurs to me that most residents would not be able to afford to buy a $55K vehicle, regardless of which fuel it uses! My income certainly would not allow me to buy one. Has this not occurred to anyone in the current administration? And, adding taxes onto already high gasoline prices would be punitive to those who are already financially struggling, just to enable those who CAN afford an expensive vehicle. This policy is like punishing someone who can only afford a used Chevy, in order to subsidize the driver of a Mercedes! |
- |
|
11/1/2019 |
Steven |
Furbish |
Retired Maine Resident |
Shapleigh |
Maine |
Most of Maine is rural and the people who live here often struggle to make ends meet. The costs of transportation in a state where public transportation is limited or non-existent is already too... read more Most of Maine is rural and the people who live here often struggle to make ends meet. The costs of transportation in a state where public transportation is limited or non-existent is already too high. Add to that the fact that Maine bills itself as "vacationland" and who would want to vacation in a state with such high taxes already and that wants to increase the cost of fuel. I oppose any increase in state fuel taxes and will vote accordingly. |
- |
|
2/28/2020 |
David |
Johnson |
retired government |
Derwood |
Maryland |
Protect the earth its the only home we have. Thanks. Protect the earth its the only home we have. Thanks. |
- |
|
12/2/2019 |
Maureen |
Earley |
Retired from USPS |
Boston |
Massachusetts |
We have voted for representatives who are supposed to represent we the people not the United Nations Agenda 2030. We voted before for no tax increase on gas and I still do not want a tax on our... read more We have voted for representatives who are supposed to represent we the people not the United Nations Agenda 2030. We voted before for no tax increase on gas and I still do not want a tax on our gas. We are taxed enough in Massachusetts. Concentrate on cleaning up the overspending on luncheons, travel, etc. |
- |
|
2/24/2020 |
John |
Wesner |
Retired from Nokia (Alcatel/Lucent) |
Pittsburgh |
Pennsylvania |
Preventing (or at least limiting) climate change is critical. Transportation is responsible for a lot of pollution that threatens to make climate change worse, It is thus critical that we put a... read more Preventing (or at least limiting) climate change is critical. Transportation is responsible for a lot of pollution that threatens to make climate change worse, It is thus critical that we put a focus on these two related areas. |
- |