|
2/21/2020 |
Josh |
Noreuil |
Commuter |
Stirling |
New Jersey |
We desperately need to modernize our public transportation in a clean and efficient manner and this proposal would do exactly that. Currently, our system is an embarrassment in that it is... read more We desperately need to modernize our public transportation in a clean and efficient manner and this proposal would do exactly that. Currently, our system is an embarrassment in that it is extremely overcrowded and constantly plagued with delays, equipment problems, vehicles that should have been retired decades ago, and over-reliance on expensive, dirty, obsolete, and taxpayer-subsidized fossil fuels. This proposal would fix many of these problems and thus should be implemented ASAP. Not only would the proposal create jobs, but it would also create a cleaner, more stress-free environment for us all -- in short, a system we could be proud of.
As a bit of a side note, it is extremely suspicious that many of the disapproving comments that are flooding this proposal appear to be generated by automated bots impersonating real people. One can only wonder who is behind this activity, but the fact that the fossil fuel companies are flush with cash and have repeatedly demonstrated a contempt for our democracy and the needs of local communities, as well as a willingness to corrupt the political and regulatory processes, points to an obvious culprit. |
- |
|
5/28/2019 |
Tom |
Rumpf |
community volunteer |
Brunswick |
Maine |
Thank you for trying to address the climate crisis in a bipartisan way by pricing carbon. I hope you will ensure that any carbon price is high enough to create sufficient incentive to reduce... read more Thank you for trying to address the climate crisis in a bipartisan way by pricing carbon. I hope you will ensure that any carbon price is high enough to create sufficient incentive to reduce carbon levels substantially, and that the policy will have a mechanism for minimizing impacts on low income folks.
Thanks. |
- |
|
11/7/2019 |
Gretchen |
Elias |
community member and parent |
MONTPELIER |
Vermont |
I strongly support this initiative. I would like to see TCI revenues invested in an equitable way, so that low and middle income households do not bear the brunt of this necessary transition.... read more I strongly support this initiative. I would like to see TCI revenues invested in an equitable way, so that low and middle income households do not bear the brunt of this necessary transition. Investments should target policies and initiatives that help transform our region from a car-dependent one to one in which gas-powered single occupancy vehicles are no longer the norm. That means significant investment in public transit as well as in alternative transportation options, EV infrastructure and subsidies/incentives for lower income households to purchase EVs, as well as smart growth land use policies, transit-oriented development, and affordable housing that is transit-accessible. |
- |
|
1/16/2020 |
Louise |
Yohalem |
Community member |
Mill River |
Massachusetts |
We need clean transportation so that fewer cars will be necessary. We need clean transportation so that fewer cars will be necessary. |
- |
|
2/28/2020 |
Jennifer |
Skinder |
Community Member |
Montpelier |
Vermont |
TCI is not nearly ambitious enough given the scale of the climate emergency. However, if specific policies are clearly defined by TCI it will provide a start in the right direction. Given that... read more TCI is not nearly ambitious enough given the scale of the climate emergency. However, if specific policies are clearly defined by TCI it will provide a start in the right direction. Given that Vermont gets all of our fossil fuels from other states, we should clearly join TCI, but must create policy that ensures equity for lower-income and rural Vermonters.
Vermont TCI should include:
-A mechanism to mitigate the impacts of TCI on low-income populations in rural areas with acknolwedgment that rural consumers must use more fossil fuels in order to get to work and commerce centers
-Higher EV and renewable energy rebates for low-income residents
-Increased weatherization funding for low and moderate income Vermonters and access to renewable energy sources via community solar development
-Development of safe roads for biking and walking, and focus on smart growth centers
-Investment in agricultural and natural responses to the climate emergency including carbon farming and forest health, acknowledging the impact of higher fuel rates on farmers, sugarmakers and others who work in agricultural and forestry professions
-Investment of TCI funds in clean energy, energy efficiency, and more robust public transportation to expand career opportunities and make jobs more accessible. The Vermont Green New Deal aims to do this, and is an essential part of all Vermont climate legislation. |
- |
|
2/26/2020 |
Octavia |
Dryden |
Community Housing & Empowerment Connections Inc. |
Bear |
Delaware |
Clean and affordable energy and transportation through an increased and appropriate level of new federal investment in zero-emissions transportation options for all community members in both rural... read more Clean and affordable energy and transportation through an increased and appropriate level of new federal investment in zero-emissions transportation options for all community members in both rural and urban areas must be a priority. This includes programs to scale up investment in public transit; zero-emissions transit buses, diesel trucks, and school buses; and accessible and affordable adoption of electric cars. We also must assure that communities impacted the most are included in decision making from the very beginning. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Barbara |
Brigham |
Community Center at Visitation |
Philadelphia |
Pennsylvania |
Fortunately my place of work as well as my house are located near to the Market-Frankford EL in Philadelphia which allows me to reach Center City in a matter of 15 minutes, meaning that I never... read more Fortunately my place of work as well as my house are located near to the Market-Frankford EL in Philadelphia which allows me to reach Center City in a matter of 15 minutes, meaning that I never need to use my car except when going to the suburbs. I hope that the efforts and plans of the east coast cities which are planning to improve public transportation services will receive your support. To have electric cars, buses and streetcars as well as bicycle paths in addition to other forms of public transport can do a lot to lessen the emissions created by cars- especially in these days when SUVs are becoming so popular. I am personally invested in these efforts as I am a person who suffers from asthma and COPD. Thank you for your attention to this matter. |
- |
|
2/4/2020 |
Dr. Michael |
Shank |
Communications Director |
Brandon |
Vermont |
I urge Vermont to formally join TCI so we can create a clean energy future that works better for everyone, especially our most vulnerable. Thank you for the work you’ve done so far to advance TCI... read more I urge Vermont to formally join TCI so we can create a clean energy future that works better for everyone, especially our most vulnerable. Thank you for the work you’ve done so far to advance TCI across the region.
TCI provides the opportunity to tackle the biggest problem of our day — climate change — by reducing emissions in our state’s most carbon-intensive sector, while diverting funds into much-needed transportation infrastructure that will benefit all.
We can either seize this opportunity to make monumental progress and have a chance to prosper in a clean energy future, or accept a status quo that is only becoming more and more difficult for Vermonters and more harmful to our environment.
Vermont, like other states, desperately needs additional funding to create innovative, equitable transportation options for all, including seniors/people with disabilities/people with low incomes, for whom transportation costs and accessibility are an added burden. TCI can provide this support.
As you know, Vermont’s participation in a cap and invest program is not new. Under Governor Jim Douglas, Vermont joined the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) in 2008. This cap and invest program covers the electric sector in the Northeast, and it has proven very successful, reducing consumer costs and carbon pollution from the power sector by 40%.
Vermont has strategically invested the revenues raised from RGGI, directing the $2 million annually into weatherization programs that help Vermonters stop wasting energy and save money. We know this type of project works — there is no excuse not to adopt TCI as well.
I urge Vermont to participate in the Transportation and Climate Initiative so that all Vermonters live in a world where they do not have to choose between being able to get where they need to go and polluting the planet irreparably.
Dr. Michael Shank
|
- |
|
12/18/2019 |
Joseph |
McKenna |
Commonwealth of MA |
Webster |
Massachusetts |
As Representative in a relatively rural district, my constituents have chosen to live outside of the city where they can enjoy the land and open spaces. The trade-off is that they must drive... read more As Representative in a relatively rural district, my constituents have chosen to live outside of the city where they can enjoy the land and open spaces. The trade-off is that they must drive every day to get to work, to doctors, to get groceries, or to get their children to and from daycare or school. TCI, and any gas tax, disproportionately places the burden of climate change onto the wallets of those living outside of cities who must drive to meet the needs of their daily lives. It is not right that those who drive often face a disproportionate tax to offset the spending of the Government. At the very least, this initiative must come before the Legislature for a vote prior to enactment. |
- |
|
1/16/2020 |
John |
Markowitz |
Columbia University |
New York |
New York |
I applaud your initiative on low-carbon transportation. We are clearly in the midst of a worsening environmental crisis that we need to reverse before it becomes irreparable. I applaud your initiative on low-carbon transportation. We are clearly in the midst of a worsening environmental crisis that we need to reverse before it becomes irreparable. |
- |
|
1/16/2020 |
Clifford |
Schorer |
Columbia University |
Greenwich |
Connecticut |
The challenge does not lie with a shortage of efficient technology. We possess all that we need. Steps to take:Set strict standards for the energy efficiency of all buildings. They are a major... read more The challenge does not lie with a shortage of efficient technology. We possess all that we need. Steps to take:Set strict standards for the energy efficiency of all buildings. They are a major source of pollution. Ratings are easy to establish and monitor and with common sense upgrades. - coupled with heavy fines for non-compliers. Utilize advanced battery technology combined with solar and wind making it possible to have an extremely energy efficient home that is not even connected to the grid. This will work now in many parts of the county. The payback is fast, the results incredible. Develop and utilize high speed rail service that will minimize the heavy pollution caused by air travel (More pollution is generated by a coast to coast flight than if every passenger drove instead. Develop dedicated truck "piggy back rail service" between regional hubs. Of course local and accessible parking are key. Reward companies for staggering work hours to maximize traffic flow. Stop subsidies for Oil and Gas production and put the savings to research. If we are serious we can accomplish in a limited time frame. |
c.pdf |
|
2/28/2020 |
Rachel |
Scott |
Collaborative Center for Justice |
Hartford |
Connecticut |
We write from the Collaborative Center for Justice, which is a faith-based advocacy organization based in Hartford, CT. We are sponsored by six congregations of Women Religious around the state... read more We write from the Collaborative Center for Justice, which is a faith-based advocacy organization based in Hartford, CT. We are sponsored by six congregations of Women Religious around the state. Environmental justice has been one of our priority areas for our education and advocacy work over the years.
We support the development of a strong multi-state Transportation and Climate Initiative and we urge Governor Lamont to fully support participating in this critical initiative. Transportation is the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions, and emissions will continue to grow if timely action is not taken to transform our transportation system. This initiative is a critically important opportunity to make changes that will lead to an increase in clean transportation and reduced greenhouse gas emissions.
We urge leaders to include provisions to prioritize investments in frontline communities that have already disproportionately borne the burdens of environmental injustices. Low-income communities and communities of color already face greater exposure to pollution from vehicle emissions, fossil fuel plants and incinerators in and near their communities. These communities need to be prioritized in the transition to clean energy. We also call upon the leaders of this initiative to meaningfully include voices from directly impacted communities in each step of the development and implementation processes.
We urge you to ensure the inclusion of the following components when developing the final program: commitment to utilizing investments to improve and expand public transportation in the state; increasing and improving bike lanes and sidewalks; and investing in expanded rail service across the state and region. This is an opportunity to make it safer, more affordable, and more possible for people to take public transportation to school and work from where they live. Increasing the frequency of buses and trains and expanding their routes are two important components to make these changes possible. It is also important to increase the availability of bike lanes so that people can safely commute from a public transit stop to another location by bike. Investment in fixing potholes, particularly on busy city streets, is also an important component of improving biker safety.
Residents who already commute to school and work by public transportation face challenges with our current system too. Many bus routes do not have frequent enough schedules to meet the needs of the residents who depend on them. In many cases, taking a bus to school or work is very time consuming because routes and connection points are limited. Bus routes need to be expanded in cities and to neighboring suburbs in order to better address this problem.
We also recommend that investments be used to transition school and public buses to electric buses. Increasing the number and expanding the locations of charging stations around the state would support the transition to electric buses and cars. Transitioning to electric buses will have important public health benefits for the children and adults who ride the buses, as well as for the wider community.
As people of faith, we concerned about the health and wellbeing of all people and our planet. We are particularly concerned about the impacts of environmental injustices on low-income communities and communities of color. We believe that there is an urgency to our actions to implement climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies. As a state and region, we have a collective responsibility to make changes to our transportation sector that will address and end these injustices, and move our society toward cleaner and more equitable transportation options in the most immediate way possible. We look forward to Governor Lamont’s leadership and commitment to this critically important initiative.
Respectfully submitted,
Dwayne David Paul – Director
Rachel Lea Scott, MSW – Associate Director
|
- |
|
11/5/2019 |
Tom |
Tietenberg |
Colby College |
Waterville |
Maine |
We know that reductions in emissions from the transportation sector are essential if we are to lower the threats posed by climate change. We also know that emissions reductions are considerably... read more We know that reductions in emissions from the transportation sector are essential if we are to lower the threats posed by climate change. We also know that emissions reductions are considerably cheaper than suffering the increases in damages that inaction brings. Further we know that the longer we wait to lower those emissions, the higher the cost will be. As someone who has studied these kinds of systems for my entire career I know of no more cost-effective and fairer approach than this type of system. I look forward to reading the comments of those who propose an alternative system capable of achieving achieve similar emissions reductions that can be demonstrated to be both fairer and more cost-effective than this proposal. |
- |
|
10/25/2019 |
Hannah |
McGhee |
Coastal Rivers Conservation Trust |
Newcastle |
Maine |
Maine needs to act now to begin reducing harmful climate-changing emissions, and to develop transportation solutions for people of all ages, abilities, and levels of income, especially in our... read more Maine needs to act now to begin reducing harmful climate-changing emissions, and to develop transportation solutions for people of all ages, abilities, and levels of income, especially in our rural areas. Working together with neighboring states to achieve this is a no-brainer. |
- |
|
1/6/2020 |
Michael |
Riley |
COASTAL MANAGEMENT GROUP LLC |
Narragansett |
Rhode Island |
"The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels" by American energy theorist Alex Epstein argues that, although sometimes labeled as "immoral," the use of fossil fuels dramatically improves... read more "The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels" by American energy theorist Alex Epstein argues that, although sometimes labeled as "immoral," the use of fossil fuels dramatically improves the overall progress of humanity, and improves life expectancy and income. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse should also read "The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels." Rhode Island will not benefit by yet another tax on its citizens. |
- |
|
11/6/2019 |
bernardo |
alayza mujica |
coasap |
Sioux City |
Iowa |
|
- |
|
8/19/2019 |
Stewart |
Schwartz |
Coalition for Smarter Growth |
Washington |
District of Columbia |
To reduce emissions from transportation we need a strong focus on the land use/transportation connection. We need to focus growth in cities and towns and in walkable, mixed-use, mixed-income,... read more To reduce emissions from transportation we need a strong focus on the land use/transportation connection. We need to focus growth in cities and towns and in walkable, mixed-use, mixed-income, transit-oriented centers and corridors. Funding transit alone will not be enough - it must be connected to compact, walkable development. Universal adoption of electric vehicles while not addressing sprawling development will mean continued long-distance driving and highway construction, while also risking the conversion of vast acreage of farms and forest to solar arrays just to supply longer distance vehicle travel. So land use must be a primary focus. As for investments to be made - they should include transit tied to land use, reduction in transit fares, affordable housing close to transit, jobs and services, and other infrastructure that supports transit-oriented communities.
The Coalition for Smarter Growth is a 22-year-old non-profit working in DC, Maryland and Virginia and the leading organization promoting walkable, transit-oriented communities (TOD) as the best way for the DC region to grow. We have convinced the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments to make TOD the core framework for regional growth in their Region Forward Plan and in their Visualize2045 long range transportation plan, however, spending practices by state and local government still include massive highway and arterial road expansion. Meanwhile the region must do more to advance public and private investment in TOD at Metrorail stations and other high capacity transit. We received the MWCOG Regional Partnership Award in 2017. |
- |
|
2/28/2020 |
Stewart |
Schwartz |
Coalition for Smarter Growth |
Washington |
District of Columbia |
See attached file See attached file |
2020.02.28 CSG Comments on TCI MOU.pdf |
|
11/5/2019 |
Sam |
Wade |
Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas |
Sacramento |
California |
Please see our attached comment letter. Please see our attached comment letter. |
191105 RNGC Comments on TCI Program Design Framework.pdf |
|
2/28/2020 |
Sam |
Wade |
Coalition for Renewable Natural Gas |
Sacramento |
California |
Attached please find our comments on the Draft MOU. Attached please find our comments on the Draft MOU. |
200228 RNGC Comments on TCI Draft MOU.pdf |