|
2/27/2020 |
Teresa |
Iovino |
civilian |
Germantown |
Tennessee |
We can't survive without clean water, land and air. We must protect our resources at all costs. read more We can't survive without clean water, land and air. We must protect our resources at all costs. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
mark |
levin |
resident |
plymouth Meeting |
Pennsylvania |
I am in favor of the plan to transform the transportation sector in this part of the country through the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). r This is a critical step to improving... read more I am in favor of the plan to transform the transportation sector in this part of the country through the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). r This is a critical step to improving transportation and addressing the climate crisis. We must invests in public transportation, biking, walking, and other programs that help to mitigate the effects of climate change. The future of our world depends on action being taken now. We have to do all we can to reduce our dependency on fossil fuels. The plan to reduce transportation emissions is a very important step. Thank you for your time and consideration in this matter.
|
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
David |
Harris |
Harris Comfort |
Bristol |
Pennsylvania |
Let the market place take a natural course. It is unfair to penalize the use of one product to subsidize another. Also electric and natural or propane vehicles are not paying a tax. Let the market place take a natural course. It is unfair to penalize the use of one product to subsidize another. Also electric and natural or propane vehicles are not paying a tax. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Christine |
Cotton |
Ms. |
Ellsworth |
Maine |
Any legislation aimed at slowing down climate change is totally necessary in this day and age! We need to do everything possible to stop it from continuing at the rate that it is. Any legislation aimed at slowing down climate change is totally necessary in this day and age! We need to do everything possible to stop it from continuing at the rate that it is. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Ann |
Pedreschi |
NRCM |
Holden |
Maine |
I truly believe all transportation should be environmentally safer than gasoline run, but if we use hybrid vehicles as I do, then we need to create natural energy to fuel them as I do. If we don... read more I truly believe all transportation should be environmentally safer than gasoline run, but if we use hybrid vehicles as I do, then we need to create natural energy to fuel them as I do. If we don't then somewhere we are creating just as much pollution as we would if driving gasoline engines. Propane buses are another alternative that has done well in Acadia National Park in part because it takes many gasoline engines out of the park. Public transport is very much needed in the USA but it is not without its own problems. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Christy |
Eppinger |
Gas Staton |
Brackenridge |
Pennsylvania |
I do not support this. I do not support this. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Shelby |
Grantham |
Concerned Citizen |
Norwich |
Vermont |
My name is Shelby Grantham. I’d like to reduce my personal carbon footprint and help reduce climate change. But I am a senior resident of Norwich, VT, living alone seven miles outside the... read more My name is Shelby Grantham. I’d like to reduce my personal carbon footprint and help reduce climate change. But I am a senior resident of Norwich, VT, living alone seven miles outside the business center of Norwich. There is no public transportation out here except the school buses, which I am not allowed to ride. I wish I didn’t have to take my car into town to get groceries and do errands.
Transportation is Vermont’s highest source of carbon emissions. As an otherwise proud citizen of Vermont, I hope the state government sees fit to join the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) that aims to develop within one year a regional policy to cap and reduce carbon emissions from transportation fuels through a cap-and-invest program that would also earn funds to help us tackle our high emissions and implement transportation solutions statewide.
Cap-and-invest programs are not new. Our Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) instituted in 2008 has reduced carbon pollution and raised funds to invest in improved weatherization that makes Vermont homes warmer and more energy efficient. With TCI, we can do the same in the transportation sector.
Across the country, cap reduction scenarios have led to environmental, health, and economic benefits. Some Vermonters may see TCI as merely a gas tax, but frankly I’m willing to pay a little more at the pumps when the outcomes are so critical and the long-term benefits so far-reaching.
Being at the table with the other TCI states will allow us to craft a VT policy that is equitable and could help us create a climate in which we can all thrive.
|
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Valerie |
Snyder |
Private citizen |
Forest Grove |
Oregon |
Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and other northeast states are considering a program that would transform the transportation sector in that part of the country through the Transportation and... read more Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and other northeast states are considering a program that would transform the transportation sector in that part of the country through the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). Clean Air Council and other advocates across the region believe this is a critical step to improving transportation and addressing the climate crisis.
If designed correctly, this program could help to create safe roads for biking and walking, more frequent and reliable public transportation, greater access to electric vehicles, and a more equitable system with cleaner transportation options for everyone in the region.
Transportation is the country’s and region’s leading source of carbon emissions. Clean Air Council believes TCI will help to clean this sector up. As a leading state in environmental protection, Oregon should join this plan to reduce transportation pollution. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Emily |
Hammel |
Boston University School of Public Health |
Boston |
Massachusetts |
The Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) seeks input from stakeholders regarding specific considerations that ought to be factored into the Model Rule and starting level for a regional cap... read more The Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) seeks input from stakeholders regarding specific considerations that ought to be factored into the Model Rule and starting level for a regional cap, compliance structure, and stability mechanisms. As a Master of Public Health student in the Environmental Health Department at Boston University School of Public Health, I offer my comments and recommendations based on my understanding of Environmental Health, Environmental Justice communities, and Environmental Policy.
The TCI aims to implement a program with four main objectives: reduce greenhouse gas emissions, improve air quality and public health, enhance transportation options, and alleviate the burden environmental justice communities bear in regards to poor air quality and limited mobility. TCI states that transportation contributes to 40% of GHG emissions in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic region; the proposed MOU is therefore appropriate to address issue of GHG emissions from the transportation sector, not only in an attempt to mitigate climate change but also to improve public health by reducing harmful co-pollutants like SO2 and NOx and increasing mobility in congested, urbanized areas. (See attachment for references)
STABILITY MECHANISMS
TCI seeks input on which factors it should consider when designing stability mechanisms for managing uncertainties in future emissions and allowance prices. The rate of reduction in emissions is critical to ensuring the sustainability of revenue needed for investment. Successful reduction from the fuel sector, and consequently fewer allowances being purchased, may cause a decline in generated revenue. The Model Rule must control the rate of reductions in order to sustain reliable revenue from fuel suppliers to invest in clean transportation alternatives. A dynamic allowance structure would provide additional stability in response to uncertainty in future emissions.
The Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) provides strategies to respond to unpredictable changes in market costs and demand in section “G. Stability Mechanisms”.
Suppliers trying to maximize profits will purchase allowances, bringing in more revenue for alternative transportation initiatives. As alternative transportation options become available, consumer demand for fuel drops. To maintain pressure on suppliers to continue reducing emissions, the cap will continue to drop over time. However, if this drop occurs too quickly, suppliers will not be inclined to buy allowances and revenues will fall. In addition to the CCR and ECR mechanisms proposed, TCI should implement a minimum cost for allowances that increases annually. This dynamic floor cost would compensate for expected long-term trends in lower demand for fuel. It also de-incentivizes industries to buy allowances, thus reducing emissions further, yet still maintains a revenue margin that allows TCI to reach its objectives. The Climate Law and Policy Project make similar recommendations in their comment under the “Accelerating Reductions” section. (See attachment for reference)
Predicting market trends and consumer behavior requires accurate models. These models can be very good, but are seldom completely accurate. To ensure the success of a TCI program, the Signatory Jurisdiction should consider additional strategies to maintain a controlled reduction rate.
COMPLIANCE
TCI also seeks input on how the compliance period should be structured to provide needed flexibility, while ensuring environmental integrity. As discussed above, the time period for compliance is closely interconnected to market dynamics. I suggest that the period ought to be stringent enough so the emissions are enforced in a reasonable time frame, though not so stringent to compromise the economy and solvency of suppliers. Too stringent and narrow of a compliance period may accelerate reductions and lead to a rapid drop in demand, which could destabilize the revenue structure needed for TCI to be successful. Allowing for offsets and allowance purchase should be permitted, but limited. The role of allowances and offsets should be primarily to control the rate of reduction, and encourage reduction rates to reflect those of development and utilization of alternative transportation measures.
I support the implementation of TCI. The initiative has four equally important objectives, three of which exist independent of the politics surrounding climate change. TCI not only reduces GHG, but also improves air quality and public health, reduces congestion and improves mobility in urban areas, and rightfully address environmental pollution issues that disproportionately burden Environmental Justice communities. All jurisdictions should support and participate in the Transportation Climate Initiative to protect individuals’ rights to a clean environment, ensure effective transportation for all, and promote health that is not burdened by the consumption behaviors of the “haves” against the “have nots”.
Respectfully,
Emily Hammel
Jamaica Plain, MA 02130
MPH Student, Boston University School of Public Health |
TCI Comments_Hammel, Emily_Final.pdf |
|
2/27/2020 |
Shobhana |
Kanal |
Unitarian Universalist Pennsylvania Legislative Action Network (UUPLAN) |
Bala Cynwyd |
Pennsylvania |
I am writing in support of the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). I urge Pennsylvania state government to do everything in our power to reduce emissions, invest in a clean transportation... read more I am writing in support of the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI). I urge Pennsylvania state government to do everything in our power to reduce emissions, invest in a clean transportation system, and reduce the impact of climate change as much as we still can.
Thank you |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Liam |
O'Sullivan |
Vermont Resident |
Burlington |
Vermont |
I am excited to see Vermont join the Transportation and Climate Initiative. Given that our emissions are still 13% above 1990 levels, with transportation acting as the biggest culprit, Vermont... read more I am excited to see Vermont join the Transportation and Climate Initiative. Given that our emissions are still 13% above 1990 levels, with transportation acting as the biggest culprit, Vermont must be looking at innovative ways to substantially decrease our emissions through 2030. Our efficiency utilities, low-income weatherization program and EV incentive program have done great things to get the ball rolling on climate action, but I fear they are not doing nearly enough to make Vermont a leader on this issue. The emission reduction goals spelled out in TCI are by no means bold, but if TCI could bring in $18-$60 million in just the first year of its implementation for substantial investments in EV incentives, EV charging infrastructure, public transportation, and returns for low-income Vermonters - while making out of state travelers pay their fair share - I'm all in. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Tammy |
Reed |
New York State |
Fairport |
New York |
Electric vehicle charging infrastructure needs to be built out and reliable. Our nation's automotive manufacturer's have staked their future on electric vehicles so that they can... read more Electric vehicle charging infrastructure needs to be built out and reliable. Our nation's automotive manufacturer's have staked their future on electric vehicles so that they can compete globally. For us as a country to not support this initiative is disheartening. Electric vehicle technology is clean and reliable. We need to be at the forefront of electrification. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Linda |
Lancaster |
Citizens' Climate Lobby - South Shore & Cape Chapter |
PLYMOUTH |
Massachusetts |
I strongly support the TCI transportation initiative. A significant percent of Massachusetts' carbon emissions comes from vehicles, and state law requires that we reduce emissions. TCI will... read more I strongly support the TCI transportation initiative. A significant percent of Massachusetts' carbon emissions comes from vehicles, and state law requires that we reduce emissions. TCI will generate revenue for investment in transportation infrastructure, including public transportation, electrifying buses, building charging stations for electric cars, and incenting citizens to drive less and buy more fuel efficient vehicles. This bill is a significant step forward in bringing down emissions, which are destroying climate and damaging public health. Please vote favorably on this bill. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Denise |
Taliaferro |
Climate Action Rhode Island (CARI) |
East Greenwich |
Rhode Island |
I support TCI because transportation is the largest source of carbon emissions in my state and we have to act on climate. I support TCI because transportation is the largest source of carbon emissions in my state and we have to act on climate. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Julia |
Candon-Nguyen |
Virginia Resident |
Lovettsville |
Virginia |
We need to push the shift to sustainable transportation aggressively. As the cost of this cap is pushed onto consumers, more and more commuters in the area will have to turn to either sustainable... read more We need to push the shift to sustainable transportation aggressively. As the cost of this cap is pushed onto consumers, more and more commuters in the area will have to turn to either sustainable vehicle options or public transportation. Of the two, I think public transportation is more effective – it doesn’t have as severe an upfront environmental impact, it helps multiple people at once, and the benefits would only increase if the vehicles themselves were green. However, the current public transportation system is too inefficient to be beneficial. If my commute to work is 15 mins by car and an hour by bus, of course I wont take the bus! The money earned from TCI needs to be applied towards improving our public transport and incentivizing people to use it. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Ruth |
Miller |
private citizen |
New York |
New York |
There is no greater threat anywhere in the world than that of climate change. Individuals can do their part. But study and implementation of regional policies to reduce carbon are indispensable... read more There is no greater threat anywhere in the world than that of climate change. Individuals can do their part. But study and implementation of regional policies to reduce carbon are indispensable to reigning in carbon emissions. Studying the climate effects of the transportation sector is essential. Climate change cannot be tackled without tackling the effects of mobility of our species on the atmosphere of the earth.
|
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Rene |
McIntyre |
Democrat |
San Francisco |
California |
Please remember that we are not the only species on this planet. We share the Earth with other species, and we should be mindful of that. Please remember that we are not the only species on this planet. We share the Earth with other species, and we should be mindful of that. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Randy |
Lisi |
Lisi Oil Co. |
Elizabethville |
Pennsylvania |
I am a petroleum jobber with 5 convenience stores in a rural part of Pennsylvania. I do not support TCI because it will not benefit our customers, as most of them will never purchase an electric... read more I am a petroleum jobber with 5 convenience stores in a rural part of Pennsylvania. I do not support TCI because it will not benefit our customers, as most of them will never purchase an electric vehicle, nor do we have mass transit in our area. Pennsylvania already has one of the highest motor fuel taxes in the United States, and the additional 17 cents per gallon would put an additional hardship on our customers. |
- |
|
2/27/2020 |
Sal |
Risalvato |
New Jersey Gasoline, C-Store, Automotive Association |
Wall |
New Jersey |
Please review attached comments. Please review attached comments. |
NJGCA Letter on TCI 02-26-20.pdf |
|
2/27/2020 |
barb |
schneiders |
retired |
Bennington |
Vermont |
fight climate change. we all need to do our part. fight climate change. we all need to do our part. |
- |